Listed below is the order. The team Captains are listed next to their picks.
| Princess Pool Party | Siblicide Squad | ||
|
Round 1
|
Dylan | Kevin Bailey | |
| Felix | Jeff Starr | ||
|
Round 2
|
Mike | Josh Conner | |
| Zig | Niko Nodal | ||
|
Round 3
|
Dylan | Kyle Foster | |
| Felix | Colin O’Brien | ||
|
Round 4
|
Mike | Mitchell Aldridge | |
| Zig | Mike Riley | ||
|
Round 5
|
Dylan | Doug schilling | |
| Felix | Josh Hicks | ||
|
Round 6
|
Mike | Nick Johnson | |
| Zig | Tyler Hamilton | ||
|
Round 7
|
Dylan | Austin Morley | |
| Felix | Logan Baird | ||
|
Round 8
|
Mike | Jeff Schwartz | |
| Zig | Dominic Cypher | ||
|
Round 9
|
Dylan | Shane Willette | |
| Felix | Jon Shaw | ||
|
Round 10
|
Mike | Joshua Lyons | |
| Zig | Drew Greenawalt | ||
|
Round 11
|
Dylan | Joe McCumber | |
| Felix | Alex Zajac | ||
|
Round 12
|
Mike | Kyle Smart | |
| Zig | Sam Lammie | ||
|
Round 13
|
Dylan | Jake Triplet | |
| Felix | Tyler Broyles | ||
|
Round 14
|
Mike | Matthew Bosco | |
| Zig | Nick Albanese | ||
|
Round 15
|
Dylan | Tanner weaver | |
| Felix | Zach Howman | ||
|
Round 16
|
Mike | CJ Houk | |
| Zig | Drew Van Asten | ||
|
Round 17
|
Dylan | Joe Rindone | |
| Felix | Robert Cameron | ||
|
Round 18
|
Mike | Jonathan Siefert | |
| Zig | Colin Hiatt | ||
|
Round 19
|
Dylan | Harrison McMinn | |
| Felix | Chakraphong Udomsilp | ||
|
Round 20
|
Mike | Matt Gregoire | |
| Zig | Spencer Bevers |
